Are We Equal in Cuba?

By Paula Henriquez

Photo: Juan Suarez

HAVANA TIMES – It’s been a while now that the issue of a so-called “egalitarian society” has been on my mind. I guess that many people may think it’s an irrelevant or, quite simply, an unknown issue, especially for our younger generations.

Truth be told, an egalitarian society is only possible in the utopian ideology of a dreamer. It’s different in reality.

Social classes have always existed and continue to exist and, as a result, the needs of these classes depends on their purchasing power. Impossible dreams become boring for some because they are excessive, while for others it’s because they are repeated to death. This has always been the case.

It’s not enough to have a good education to reach the next rung on the social ladder. The relationships you are able to form, being sharp or having mid-to-long-term vision, your eloquence and powers of conviction are much more important. Although in most cases what you need is a privileged surname..

Generally-speaking, the latter are normally the ones who climb the ladder the highest, and with the least amount of effort, of course. It’s not unusual for many people to lack the key ingredients to win over the space they are in.

So, we see them filling management roles in companies and other important positions. And, as you can imagine, this is where bad decisions or inefficient management stem from. The population pays the price.

Going back in time

I sometimes remember my childhood years, with nostalgia. I think that was the closest I ever came to that utopian dream of an economically egalitarian society.

It goes without saying that back then, my age didn’t allow me to comprehend the twists and turns of the era… nor was I interested in learning the reasons behind what was happening around me. Maybe this is why I remember it as a golden age in my life.

Then came the collapse of the Soviet Bloc and the dismemberment of what we knew as the Soviet Union.

This is where the most notable class differences began. Huge gaps opened up between people’s lifestyles.

At that time, I was old enough to begin to see it. Thirty years have passed since and nothing has changed for the better. Every year, you dream that the next might be better than the present year, and so on. Maybe this is the perfect mechanism to push your mind and keep going.

The truth is that many lucky people were already at the top and they continue to enjoy the same privileges. Another few, closer in age to my generation, managed to climb up a rung or two on the social ladder. They combined some of the above ingredients that are so important to “get you to the top”. 

It’s not that I spend my days haunted by the idea of climbing the social ladder, it’s a matter of luck at the end of the day… nevertheless, I still hold onto my dreams and, every once in a while, I stop and look back to the past with nostalgia, thinking back to that utopian dream of social equality.

Read more from Paula Henriquez here.

Paula Henriquez

Paula Henriquez: Since childhood I have been told I should be careful what I say in public. "Think before you speak, especially in front of others," my mother would say, and it was more of a plea than a scolding. Even today I hear her and I obey her, just that I do not speak, I write. Letters and words are my escape, my exit and daily catharsis, which printed on paper, revive me. And this picture is my refuge.


13 thoughts on “Are We Equal in Cuba?

  • October 31, 2020 at 5:19 pm
    Permalink

    Mr MacD,
    Your comment is somewhat scattergun but interesting nonetheless.
    I do not suggest that you are ‘immune to the multitudes who live in misery in this world‘.
    I actually suggested that ‘on the rare occasions that you manage put your fixation with your dastardly Castros to one side, you might actually self-express some degree of concern regarding the sickening and ever-increasing fact of global inequality.’
    I do not, as you suggest, scorn charity. In fact I consider it a moral duty to pay my legal taxes wherever I reside and furthermore, to give extra toward those who fall foul of the global capitalist system which still has much in common with it’s medieval and feudal roots. Democratic pretensions are all very luvvy and nice but in most cases they do not obscure the hard-nose Capitalist reality.
    To me it’s abundantly clear that Communism, as has been practiced thus far, ain’t the answer.
    But it is even more abundantly clear that Capitalism, which has been practiced for far longer and far more widely, ain’t the answer either.
    Ultimately perhaps some kind of devilish hybrid of the two?
    But that certainly would not be arrived at from any kind of Conservative, Capitalist starting point.
    The considered Conservative, Capitalist opinion is to continue with yet more of the same old sh*t.
    Fully Understandable.
    Why on earth would anyone wish to give up their control of centuries-old capital??

  • October 31, 2020 at 3:18 pm
    Permalink

    So Nick, do away with capitalism and what have you got? Equality of poverty as illustrated in true communist dictatorships, for example North Korea? Even China and Vietnam have illustrated the need to introduce capitalism if seeking improvement in living standards for citizenry.
    As usual you try to insinuate that those of us who recognize the need for capitalism are immune to the multitudes who live in misery in this world. That really is unworthy of you. Although you no doubt would scorn charity, the largest single supporter of medical aid in Africa is the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation – not any of the political far-left states, and average individuals like myself support people in third world countries troubled by far-left terrorism through other charities – in my case Mali. When people flee from oppression – usually in far-left countries, they do not seek to re-locate to other far-left countries, but to capitalist ones where they have a degree of freedom not only banned but abhored by the far-left.
    Obviously there is a certain smug satisfaction to be obtained in endeavoring to illustrate that capitalism is at fault for all the sins and errors of this world. But the alternative has little if anything, to offer. Perhaps you rather than taking the easy route of criticizing, can be constructive and enunciate a valid alternative?

  • October 30, 2020 at 4:08 pm
    Permalink

    I like the riposte Mr MacD….
    It is admirably flippant. The ability to use flippancy in an appropriate fashion is a woefully under-regarded talent.
    But no fixation with Cuba’s innate problems will ever obscure the overarching reality of Capitalism circa 2020.
    I’m afraid that despite your every stalwart apologist attempt, the very ethos of the capitalist system is that the ladder of the rich is propped up by the misery of the poor.
    44% of global wealth is owned by 1% of the world’s population.
    Meanwhile, children in the third world go down underground risking their already shortened life expectancies to mine minerals necessary for the usage of those further up the global capitalist ladder.
    Whatever changes occur in Cuba, it won’t alter their bigger picture of wealth on the back of misery to which you will seemingly forever turn something of a blind eye.
    However, I do suspect that on the rare occasions that you manage put your fixation with your dastardly Castros to one side, you might actually self-express some degree of concern regarding the sickening and ever-increasing fact of global inequality.
    On the other hand you might not.
    A couple of comments ago I pointed out that inequality is on a massive comprehensive global upward curve.
    There is no adequate pro-capitalist riposte to this irrefutable and sad fact.

  • October 29, 2020 at 10:08 pm
    Permalink

    It is in Cuba NIck, and the last time I checked, Cuba was of the extreme left – Communist

  • October 28, 2020 at 2:08 pm
    Permalink

    And under a typical Capitalist regime Mr MacD?
    Is the ladder of the rich inevitably propped up by the misery of the poor??

  • October 28, 2020 at 12:04 pm
    Permalink

    The communist social ladder leans against a house built of straw for support.

  • October 27, 2020 at 3:19 pm
    Permalink

    Aaaah!! The nostalgia for the dreams of our younger selves.

    Communists promise equality of wealth and resources.
    Capitalists promise the equality of opportunity to climb to the top of the ladder of luxury and riches.
    Religionists of various different persuasion promise that we are all equal in the eyes of God.

    Paula writes a very good article. She is correct to observe that inequality has increased since the demise of the Soviet Bloc. This applies in Cuba, Russia and most other places in Europe and the Americas and arguably pretty much everywhere else in the world.

    Presumably there are many who think that ever increasing inequality is no bad thing?
    Others just wait around to see if that long promised trickle-down is ever gonna happen……..

  • October 27, 2020 at 1:28 pm
    Permalink

    Just go to the Instagram, and Facebook of the Castro families son, daughters and grandchildren and you would see then on vacation in Paris , London ,Madrid having la dolce vita and the rest of the Cubans waiting in lines For 5,6 hours to buy a bag of chicken then think how equals Cubans are.
    Did I mention that the chickens are from USA ? The embargo does not apply to food and medicine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *