Cuba and a New Special Period on the Horizon: Possible Responses from Havana

A brief review of the 1990-2004 crisis

Photo: Juan Suarez

Por Alfredo Fernandez

HAVANA TIMES – An old man eats a typical Cuban meal in a workers’ canteen, in front of TV cameras. TV viewers didn’t think too much of it: white rice, black bean stew, avocado salad and a juicy pork steak. Some people even found it to be mockery as getting your hands on a meal like that was quite the feat in Cuba back then (summer of 1993).

After cutting into the steak and enjoying that feast, the man looks at his compliant entourage and confirms what they had told him. The incredible likeliness of grapefruit peel with pork.

This is when TV viewers discover that this meat doesn’t exist, that the man isn’t eating animal protein, or any other living being’s meat, but is actually wolfing down a “grapefruit steak”; right in front of the National News on TV.

Although this wasn’t seen by every TV viewer, as there were blackouts lasting, eight, twelve and sixteen hours, it did reach enough people for it to be the word on Cuba’s streets the next morning. Oh, and the man was no other than First Secretary of the Cuban Communist Party and Head of the State Council and Council of Ministers at the time; Fidel Castro.

The above scene only gives you a hint at what the Cuban government was willing to do to smooth over, in some way or another, the extreme economic crisis Cuba was experiencing in the 1990s. Up until then, the island had been financially dependent on the USSR, and when it collapsed in 1991, it had to deal with its GDP falling 35%. This became the most violent financial disaster the country had experienced ever since it became a Republic on May 20, 1902.

Photo: Juan Suarez

In April 1994, a woman returned to the island to visit her daughter and grandchildren, eight years after emigrating to the US. Seeing the situation her family was in with her own two eyes, she prayed to God for a miracle so that she could take them to Miami, as soon as possible. She is a believer, but she had no idea just how quickly God was going to answer her. The woman, a Havanan through and through, urges her daughter, son-in-law and her grandchildren, to cross the bay in a boat to Casablanca. They would see the sunset from the Havana Christ statute. There, they would enjoy a snack bought with imported dollars.

Getting on the boat was a little bit of a bother this time. As a group of men carrying two cakes and some crates of beer to celebrate a wedding, got onboard in addition to the normal number of passengers. As they traveled over the trip’s distance of a little more than a kilometer, the woman was left stunned as she watched some men take guns out of the cake and threaten the captian with death if he didn’t change the boat’s route and head, in fact, for the US.

At high sea already, the owner spoke to some of the calmer hijackers, “there wasn’t enough fuel to cover such a distance.” The hijackers weren’t carrying beer in the many beer bottles they had brought onboard, but enough fuel for a boat of this kind to reach New York. Once in international waters, the boat was intercepted by the US Coast Guard. The passengers who wanted to enter the US were granted entry, the rest went back to the island. So, this woman, who thought about watching a sunset over Havana with her family from Christ, suddenly found herself involved in the luckiest event of her life, by absolute chance.

A few months later, the seaside town of Cojimar, to the east of Havana, became a place of farewells to makeshift rafts. Although, to tell you the truth, scenes of entire families boarding shaky boats to try and get to the US or the US Naval Base in Guantanamo, became an everyday occurrence in any coastal town in Cuba. Never-ending hugs, heartfelt sobbing, santeria rituals in plain sight, Our Ladies of Charity, or Regla, perched on the boat’s “prow”.

Meanwhile, the Cuban Government implemented unprecedented measures, especially against their socialist praxis, in order to save their project. This was how the foreign investment law was born, with unobstructed investments of this kind of capital in the nickel, tourism industries, for example.

Photo: Juan Suarez

Cubans were allowed to carry dollars as hard currency. People were allowed to work for themselves; licenses were created for restaurants, cafes, costume jewelry sales, etc. Agro-markets were allowed again; which had been closed down the decade before as the government believed them to be dregs of capitalism.

In December 1998, the former colonel of the Venezuela’s Armed Forces became that country’s president, winning the elections; Hugo Chavez Frias, who never hid his admiration for Fidel Castro, before coming into power. Now, Castro would be able to make his rancid dream come true (which had been put on standby ever since his first trip to Caracas in 1948): have access to Venezuelan oil so as to spread the revolution across Latin America.

Cuba and a new Special Period on the horizon

The gap left in the Cuban economy by the USSR’s collapse, would then be filled by oil-rich Venezuela. When Chavez passed away in early 2013, he passed on his power to his greatest confidant, former Foreign Relations Minister, Nicolas Maduro. From that moment on, the Venezuelan economy’s decline became even more apparent, with lower oil prices and a reduced leadership in particular. Venezuela’s financial disaster came soon after and, of course, it had a series of repercussions on the Cuban economy.

Right now, the aid that Venezuela sends Havana has declined greatly. 2012 was the peak of this aid with over 8.5 billion USD being sent to Cuba in collaborations. Compared to 2018, with only 2 billion USD being sent, a sharp drop. In the face of this situation, the Cuban government has opted to implement a series of its own measures. It’s worth analyzing them in today’s context.

On December 16th 2014, President Obama decided to withdraw various clauses from the US embargo against the Cuban government. It was pretty much a done deal in his eyes and he even released the Cuban 5 (alleged spies who were serving prison sentences in the US) as a greater gesture yet. While these gestures were initially celebrated by Cuban president Raul Castro, the government adopted a cautious stance. Convinced that Hillary Clinton would win the upcoming presidential elections, the Cuban government delayed the toughest decisions.

Certain that the Democrats would continue in power, Raul Castro knew that they wouldn’t be interested in walking away from this dialogue process. However, Fate punished so much restraint, and the unpredictable tycoon Donald Trump set up camp in the White House in January 2017.

Next? The dialogue came to an end, and the Republican party not only went back on everything outlined by Obama, but lifted the waiver on Title III of the Helms-Burton Act on May 2nd 2019. One of the most cutting sections for the Cuban economy in this statute. The title in question “authorizes Cuban exiles and US citizens to file lawsuits against those who traffic Cuban properties, or US properties seized in Cuba.”

The Cuban government’s most innovative responses to this crackdown on the embargo include the Cuban exile community’s ability to invest in the country. Ever since the beginning of the current decade, upmarket Cuban-American businessmen such as: Carlos Saladrigas, the Fanjul Gómez-Mena brothers, Jorge Perez and the Bacardi heirs, to name a few, have all been in talks with the Cuban government.

Right now, it’s crucial that the Cuban government finds investors who invest at least 2.5 billion USD per year, in order to save the economy from collapse. Foreign investments in Cuba today don’t even amount to 1 billion USD, so it will be impossible for the national GDP to grow any more than 2% per year.

Recent news of business plans to be established by employees of state companies themselves has come as a real surprise. As it seemed like every “change” would be in the powerful hands of foreign investment. The current president of the State Council and Council of Ministers, Miguel Diaz-Canel, has announced that beginning January 2020, businesses will be free to draw up their own financial plans, with their employees, and will also be able to discuss their viability. Yet, details are still unknown. The same goes for permits for Cubans living abroad to invest.

Photo: Juan Suarez

Cuba: This time there won’t be an escape valve

While there haven’t been clear signs of an immigration crisis from Cuba to the US (Cubans have been emigrating to the US via Central America for years now), there also hasn’t been any sign that the current US government will respond in the same way it did with the 1980 immigration crisis (Peruvian Embassy – Mariel) and 1994 (rafters’ crisis), when it was willing to welcome thousands of Cubans arriving on its shores.

While President Donald Trump hasn’t said anything about this yet, the way he has tried to put the brakes on Latin American and Muslim immigration. We can guess that this time there won’t be a new immigration crisis. As a result, the Cuban government won’t be able to use this escape valve that has worked so well in the past.

Will the Cuban government survive a new Special Period?

One of the answers to this question was shaped by FLACSO researcher Delia Luisa Lopez. According to whom: “the crisis (known by Cubans as the “Special Period”) won’t also lead to the collapse of the Cuban Revolution, even with its shortages of food, raw materials and poorer quality of life for the population.”

According to the researcher, the equation “economic crisis= political crisis and both = collapse of the entire system”, won’t happen in Cuba because while the government has faced many economic crises over the years, it has never suffered a political crisis and the Castros’ leadership was always stable and became even stronger with every economic crisis.

The above sheds some light on one of the possible routes of the potential “Special Period” that is threatening Cubans, today. You need to bear in mind the fact that an analysis of this kind that the collapse of the Soviet Bloc in Eastern Europe, was the result of purely political decisions and these aren’t visible on the Cuban landscape today.

It appears that the economic crisis that might befall the Cuban people in upcoming months, won’t be accompanied by a political crisis. Thus, it is very unlikely that the Cuban government will go anywhere in the short-term. At least this is what History has shown us, up until today. So, talking about the collapse of the Cuban government in the next six months or year is unlikely.

Alfredo Fernandez

Alfredo Fernandez: I didn't really leave Cuba, it's impossible to leave somewhere that you've never been. After gravitating for 37 years on that strange island, I managed to touch firm ground, but only to confirm that I hadn't reached anywhere. Perhaps I will never belong anywhere. Now I'm living in Ecuador, but please, don't believe me when I say where I am, better to find me in "the Cuba of my dreams.

Alfredo Fernandez has 177 posts and counting. See all posts by Alfredo Fernandez

21 thoughts on “Cuba and a New Special Period on the Horizon: Possible Responses from Havana

  • I would like to think that you are correct Michael, but that thirst for power and control by communism over ever more people never dies in the breast of people like Raul Castro, It has driven him since he visited the USSR in 1953. Fidel and Raul Castro nurtured both Chavez and Maduro, as Chavez commented: “Fidel Castro is like a father to me.”.

  • I would like to think that you are correct Michael, but that thirst for power and control by communism over ever more people never dies in the breast of people like Raul Castro, It has driven him since he visited the USSR in 1953. Fidel and Raul Castro nurtured both Chavez and Maduro, as Chavez commented: “Fidel Castro is like a father to me.”.

  • Independence is very costly at so many levels .

  • Argentina openly trades with Cuba, despite the “embargo”
    Isn’t Argentina known for the quality of its beef products?

    This is one more deficiency in Cuba that can’t be blamed on that darned “embargo”!

  • Hello Bruce. You are correct in saying that nothing positive for the Cuban people has come from the US embargo, the advantages as I explained, have all been for the Castro regime itself.
    Let us not be fooled into imagining that the Castro regime offers the Cuban people anything other than repression, denial of human rights as defined by the UN, and total lack of freedom of choice.
    Fidel Castro posed as one who was leading a revolution that would free the people of Cuba from the Batista dictatorship and who deliberately lied about his purpose even following the revolution:
    March 16th 1959:

    “There can be no danger if we do what the Cubans want, if we provide social practice and solve the substantial social problems of all Cubans of liberty, of respect for individual rights, of freedom of the press and thought, of democracy, of liberty to select their own government.”

    That analysis was correct – but entirely contrary to his subsequent actions which followed communist doctrine and practice as observed by Raul Castro in the USSR in April 1953.
    Fidel Castro himself, admitted that the revolution itself was not communist – for it included many who were anti-communist and as late as December 14th, 1959, said:

    “They have no right to accuse the revolution of being communist.”

    That statement was made during the trail and purging of 39 revolutionaries who being anti-communist were jailed – another leading opponent and Head of the military, Camilo Cienfuegos having conveniently disappeared, allowing Raul Castro to be promoted to fill that role.
    Just as no reasonable person can deny that yet another Cuban revolution was inevitable following the establishment of the Batista dictatorship, no reasonable person can deny that dictatorship whether by the right or left, is an evil.
    Two wrongs Bruce, do not make a right!
    If it is correct to criticize US military actions in other countries, is it not equally correct to criticize the Castro regime similarly? Nobody either Bruce, should forget Fidel Castro urging for a nuclear first strike against the US:

    “however harsh and terrible such a decision would be.”

    The whole world has to be grateful that Castro himself did not control the nuclear button, for as Nikita Khrushchev explained, such action would inevitably have led to a Third World War.
    It was not until 1961 that Fidel Castro eventually admitted that:

    “I have been a Marxist-Leninist all along and will remain one until I die.”

    That from a man who in 1952 had stood as a candidate for the Orthodox Party of Cuba, which supported corporation and labour rights, direct democracy and respect for private ownership.
    With his wonderful physique, eloquence, legal training and charismatic character, Fidel Castro had the opportunity to meet the requirements which he himself correctly defined as reflecting the wishes of the people of Cuba for liberty, and by so doing could have entered the history books of humanity along with Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela, but he chose otherwise, he in his thirst for total power and control chose communism and dictatorship. The people of Cuba have suffered the consequences.

  • Hi: Carlyle.

    As much as I don’t believe the U.S embargo on Cuba is the entire problem, It certainly is a big part of the problem. The unnecessary suffering of Cuban citizens is only being made worse with the draconian embargo.

    Nothing positive for the Cuban people comes from the embargo. For 60 years the USA has been screwing Cuba for what ? because Fidel kicked the Americans out & took what property & businesses they had there.

    From what I have read, live was not so great in Cuba under Batista’s time. I have read that the U.S mobsters ran all the night clubs, strip clubs, casinos & mostly everything else. More shocking is how these same U.S mobsters were sexually abusing Cuban girls as young as 12 years of age .

    So from what I can see, Fidel Castro did a good thing to same Cuba’s people from Batista & America. The original idea of the revolution & even of a communist state, I’m sure seemed like a good idea to Castro even though it has not worked out so well in the long term.

    I fairly certain that Fidel’s efforts to over through Batista & kick America out of Cuba was not so his people could live in substandard conditions & only make 20 – 30 Dollars per month.

    This is where I feel the U.S embargo on Cuba comes into play & has magnified the suffering of the innocent citizens of Cuba.

  • The situation will be very similar to what West Germany discovered after German reunification. The East German economy and living standards were discovered to be far worse than even the staunchest conservatives would have believed.

  • No, I think he preferred the mango ones! LOL

  • That’s a product that they’ll be able to export profitably to the US, after that darned embargo gets lifted! LOL

  • That, I think, is exactly the problem. Also, there are now three generations of Cubans who have been sealed off from the outside world and have no knowledge of any type of society other than Moscow-styled communism!
    Remember that Fidel banned the distribution of even periodicals from the USSR, after Gorbachev began his reforms.

  • I think that by the time of Chavez’s accession to power in Venezuela, even Fidel and Raul were no longer thinking in terms of “exporting” the revolution anywhere.

  • “& can be free to live their lives as they see fit.” A wonderful sentiment Bruce!
    Cubans currently and for the previous sixty weary years, have been forced to live under a totalitarian communist dictatorship. That is a factual statement. They have had no choice! Doing so has not been a consequence of actions by the US, but by the slavish adherence to the 19th century philosophy of Marx and Engels as interpreted by Lenin, effected by Stalin and adopted by the Castro brothers following Raul Castro visiting the USSR in April, 1953.
    I see no reason why the Canadian taxpayer should pay to send regular supplies of food, medical and health supplies to support the Castro regime. The real answer to Cuba’s problems is the ending of totalitarian rule and adoption of multi-party democracy of the type that you as a Canadian enjoy.
    Do not accuse me of being “heartless”, for I am married to a Cuban and our home is in Cuba along with our extended family, friends and pet dog.
    Don’t be fooled Bruce by the claims that Cuba’s problems are a consequence of actions by the US, which only exacerbate the innumerable faults of the Castro regime. My own opposition to the embargo is because it has been used ceaselessly as an excuse by the Castro regime for all the consequences of their dictate, managerial incompetence and failures.
    I like you, wish to see Cubans able to live their lives as they see fit – a joy that they are currently denied!

    “For the people of Cuba there remains only that faint hope which they have tenaciously clung onto for so many long years. Hope for the younger generations that they may yet know freedom and opportunity to live in their beautiful country free from repression, with freedom of expression, freedom of the media and freedom to vote for political parties of choice. Cubans deserve no less, for only then will they become members of an open society in a free world that waits to welcome them with open arms. Liberty and that poignant cry for freedom beckon and humanity demands.”

    Cuba Lifting The Veil

  • I’m so angry with what the USA is doing to hurt the Cuban people. The embargo does nothing to evoke change in Cuba’s government & only punishes it citizens.

    I’m a 53 year old Canadian whom travels to Cuba once a year. I bring as much as I can to help local Cubans when I visit. I wish the Canadian & other governments of the world would step up & send regular supplies of food, medicine & medical supplies as well as health & hygiene items.

    My heart truly go’s out to the innocent citizens of Cuba whom are victims of Americas disgusting, heartless & immoral embargo.

    I pray that in 2020 Americans see how wrong they were to have voted for the heartless bastard that is their current President.

    I hope the next U.S. President & congress will see how wrong this embargo against Cuba is & will lift it completely and stop inflicting so much pain on those innocent citizens.

    If America does not like the Cuban government, that is their choice but don’t punish Cuba’s citizens & literally invoke genocide on the people of Cuba. Sadly this is what America is doing to Cuba’s people.

    America claims to be the perfect model of democracy but in my opinion, America is the worlds biggest dictator. They use their military, & financial powers to dictate & control other nations. How is this democracy & not a dictatorship.

    I pray to God that the people of Cuba will soon be free from Americas choke hold & can be free to live their lives as they see fit.

  • This will kill the tourist industry except for all inclusive hotel stays. Cuba was told 5 years ago this was likely. They chose to continue to run a corrupt government were people had to cheat to survive. Mexico will be very pleased that tourists will go there or to other countries ahead of Cuba. The U.S. is putting the Cuban people in a very bad position if they will not accept them.

  • Get Up – Stand Up Cuba For Your Children,s Rights. Great writing Alfredo I wish your Words Reach The World In Time To Save The Children. Why the Canadian Government Has Hidden The Real inside of Cuba for so many years.

  • Grapefruit steak, this must be the key to Cuban longevity, I’ll bet they’d trade in a few years to taste a real beef steak.

  • Fidel never ate a grapefruit steak in his entire life.

  • It’s a fact that throughout the years this government has been able to plant fear in the brain of Cubans. No matter what they do against them their only goal is to leave Cuba.

  • Cuba “,the most beautiful place man has sets eyes on.” So they say Columbus said. Its wreak people just don’t care.
    Cuba is going to to need 100 years to rebuild.

  • Only for the camera did Fidel do that. He ate good steaks and every tasty food at his people’s expense. No hero here.

  • Keep on writing brother. Your recent articles have been a great addition to HT. I will leave the comments to others because what will happen when is only speculation. But Fidel dutifully eating a grapefruit-peel steak to demonstrate his loyalty to his own ideas is a great image that was new to me.

Comments are closed.