Venezuela’s Heavy Industry Faces Multiple Woes

Humberto Márquez

HAVANA TIMES, Oct. 5 (IPS) — Like the biblical plagues of Egypt, 10 calamities have fallen in recent years on the previously flourishing basic industries of northeastern Venezuela, such as iron and steel, aluminum and hydroelectricity.

Lack of investment, the collapse of product prices, technological obsolescence, power failures, and shortage of supplies, patronage, corruption, and debt, a backlog in workers’ wages and benefits, and environmental degradation are the problems most frequently raised by trade unionists, business owners and analysts.

As a result, the plight of state-owned heavy industry puts a spanner in the works of the private sector, social and labor conflicts are on the increase, and hopes for a diversified economy, overcoming dependency on oil, are fading away in this region bordering Guyana, and Brazil farther south.

“Nearly all the basic industries have the same problems: supplies, spare parts and equipment fail to arrive, paralyzing production lines; payrolls are padded, labor agreements are violated and the executives who run them play politics but do not manage competently,” steelworkers’ union leader José Jiménez complained to a group of foreign correspondents visiting the area, including IPS.

In the aluminum industry, “production is crashing, together with the work ethic, while schools to supposedly teach Marxism to the workers are mushrooming,” said aluminum union leader José Luis Morocoima, who is recovering from a bullet wound to the head he sustained in a labor conflict in May.

“The fall in production in state-owned basic industries has led to the closure of 162 out of 310 factories in the sector. In those that remain, use of installed capacity is less than 40 percent,” said the president of the regional Chamber of Industry and Mining, Fernando Goyenechea.

Analyst Damián Prat, who has been following the history of this sector for the past 30 years, said “the decline in production began in 2005, and the common denominator has been falling investment and maintenance, payroll expansion and corruption.”

The group of heavy industry companies in the region of Guyana developed in the last four decades of the 20th century around the confluence of the Orinoco and Caroní rivers, about 550 km southeast of Caracas.

The idea was to take advantage of the area’s enormous potential in iron, bauxite, precious metals and other minerals, hydroelectricity, forest resources and tourism based on stunning scenery, like plunging waterfalls and flat-topped mountains.

A system of dams was built in the lower Caroní River, which is 900 km long with an average flow rate of 5,000 cubic meters per second. The outflow from an artificial lake, the Guri, covering 4,000 square km, drives hydroelectric turbines in three power plants with an installed capacity of 12,500 megawatts. A fourth is being built, although it is behind schedule.

The main dam on Guri Lake feeds 20 turbines with a capacity of 10,000 megawatts; 14 turbines are in operation while the others are shut down or undergoing repairs, the correspondents found.

The availability of electricity drove the installation of Siderúrgica del Orinoco (SIDOR), a steel company that was originally state-owned, then sold in 1997 to the Ternium Group, belonging to the Argentine consortium Techint, and nationalized again in 2008.

In the latter years of the last decade, while it was still owned by Ternium and employed 5,000 workers, SIDOR produced 4.3 million tons of steel annually. In contrast, with twice the workforce, it has only produced 2.1 million tons so far in 2011 and is forecast to reach 2.6 million tons by the end of the year.

SIDOR is supplied by Ferrominera Orinoco, which mines iron ore in the area and sells it as iron ore, pellets and briquettes. From its past record of 20 million tons per year, Ferrominera’s production fell last year to 13 million tons, according to the head of the trade union at the company, Rubén González.

Some six billion tons of bauxite (aluminum ore) reserves in the Orinoco river valley gave rise to the alumina and primary aluminum metal industry, and the foundation of the ALCASA and Venezolana de Aluminio (VENALUM) companies, with a joint nominal production capacity of over 600,000 tons a year.

Related industries like the Carbonorca Company which makes carbon anodes for aluminum smelters, and FESILVEN which produces special alloys for the steel industry, have also grown up in the area. All these companies, according to reports from trade unionists and private business owners, are currently experiencing steep declines in production, taking on excess employees, and suffering from lack of investment, technological backwardness and shortage of materials.

At Carbonorca, “the workforce was increased from 470 employees to 700, for political reasons. Many of these people do not even have a chair to sit on, or they spend hours playing computer games, but many others keep working hard, producing the anodes that help our fellow workers at ALCASA to keep their production line going,” said union representative Emilio Campos.

While debate continues over what should have been done and how much should have been invested in these Guyana companies, there was a severe drought in 2009-2010 which led to enforced power rationing and obliged firms like VENALUM to shut down half its electrolysis cells, in order to spare entire cities in the north of the country from power outages.

Power consumption at VENALUM “is 800 megawatt-hours, half of what Caracas (with its five million people) uses, and we had to shut down more than 400 out of our 905 electrolysis cells. In 2008 we produced 439,000 tons of aluminum, but output fell to 258,000 tons in 2010,” Rada Gamluch, the company’s “worker-president”, told the journalists.

“The Socialist Guyana Plan that we are putting into practice aims for the gradual recovery of VENALUM, with a production target of 270,000 tons for this year, 300,000 next year and over 400,000 tons in 2014,” Gamluch announced.

According to his calculations, an injection of 400 million dollars from state coffers would allow payment of the money owed to workers and suppliers, as well as paying VENALUM’s overdue power bills from the state electricity company, which go back two years.

But Prat, the analyst, said “VENALUM’s decline began even before the electricity crisis.” In 2004 it reported net profits of 60 million dollars although aluminum was only worth 1,500 dollars a ton, yet it made a loss in 2006, when international prices rose above 2,500 dollars a ton, although it produced similar amounts of the metal in both years.

Bad management and heavy politicization were to blame for these problems, according to critics. Wages were increased, apparently for electoral reasons, and there was also proselytism by the ruling party and corruption, they say.

Several sources mentioned the possible abuse of mandatory quotas – proportions of production – reserved for national producers, which some middlemen allocate abroad in order to profit from the difference in exchange rates. Venezuela has rigid exchange, price and tariff controls.

Labor conflicts are the order of the day, mainly sparked by delayed payment of workers’ wages, in a context where basic industry companies have 45,000 employees but could operate with 12,000, according to Goyenechea.

The companies have also been the scenario of a great deal of violence, which dogs labor and trade union activity in the construction sector in Guyana.

And environmental protection has been lax, especially in the aluminum smelters.

To set the firms back on their feet, the centrist opposition party Un Nuevo Tiempo (A New Era) proposed in February – without success – a bill to create a 3.1 billion dollar fund. Goyenechea estimated that recovery of the basic industry companies and further development of local natural resources would take at least twice that amount.

The military dictatorship of Marcos Pérez Jiménez (1948-1958), the two-party democracy that reigned from 1958 to 1998, and the “Bolivarian socialism” instituted by President Hugo Chávez since 1999, have all shared a vision of a promising, bright future for the Guyana region in the northeast and southeast and its industries. It is still a long way off.


3 thoughts on “Venezuela’s Heavy Industry Faces Multiple Woes

  • Not sure about that, I live in a Socialist Canadian province that owned it’s monopoly sector. Unfortunately, the oil & mining sector was sold off by a spendthrift conservative government in the 1980’s & we lost a mining giant that used to return several hundred million to the provincial treasury annually. Stock symbol POT. The Phone system, Gas network, electrical, & bus systems & home & car insurance was all government owned. We had the lowest rates in Canada for all the above utilities & expenses even though we had the highest infrastructure costs you could imagine, serving a million residents that are spread out over such a vast area. (Saskatchewan) The phone company pioneered internet protocols that were licenseable worldwide. The insurance company was so competitive that it’s foreign offices sold policies in other jourisdictions & returned a dividend to the local coffers. The phone company often was able to profitably bid on foreign contracts to develop phone systems internationally & remain competitive. Everybody wanted one of these “government” jobs because they were secure & had solid independent unions. As for myself, I work for a municipality & although I’m not an owner, I find being a public servant has rewards. You help others without some power tripping capitalist crony exploiting your labour. Sadly, although scandals were few, the electorate has decided (brainwashed by the right-wing media) in favour of a right-wing government that is selling off government lands & assets, even foreign ones, regardless if they’re profitable or not! Oh, yeah socialized medical care exists here. That’s government funded & is run on a non-profit model. Any citizen (as a birthright or via residency) can walk into a hospital or doctor’s office & receive free healthcare. The cost per-capita is about half of the U.S. cost according to census data.
    State ownership is a minor detail. I know that the head of the potash corporation used to make about $385,000 annually & now that it is a capitalist entity with the head office is in Chicago, the CEO makes about 100-400 MILLION & was estimated to be worth over a billion if he excercised his stock options. Who knows what the rest of the board makes? Education here is government run, but sadly, you can only lead a horse to water.

  • A capitalist country cannot be run successfully by a socialist government because state ownership and control of industry destroys the productive process. What Venezuela needs is what every country needs, a socialist government that does not nationalize industry, but that converts ownership of it to working-associates through Mondragon-style cooperative corporate structures. Venezuela needs to operate according to what has proved successful in the world, not according to what has proved a failure.

  • Wow, and there was me thinking Chavez was the messiah or at least a living God and Venezuela a beacon to the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *