Civility Threatened in Cuba

By Amrit

From the documentary Muy Bien.

HAVANA TIMES, Feb 22 — Some time ago I saw a Cuban documentary about elementary school education here.  To teach the pronunciation of the letter “f,” the teacher used the word “firearm” – not flower, or fiesta or fun…words that are closer to children. With an emphatic pause, she pronounced: FIRE-ARM, and proceeded to make those innocent students repeat those same syllables.

Just recently my teenage son showed me his math book, in which he had noticed a recurring — coincidental? — focus.  Let me give a few examples:

“If a box has 100 bullets, and you use a quarter of them in a shooting practice…”

Another begins: “In a military maneuver, a truck is carrying seven crates of rifles…”

From the documentary Muy Bien.

A third gives the example of “the tenth regiment from the Camilo Cienfuegos Military School (EMCC)” in order to finally ask how many sacks of potatoes were collected by the students.

This made me wonder what the relevance of it being a military school was. Are cadets the only students who harvest potatoes?

Why can’t figures come from situations that are more immediate to the students themselves? For example: “In a fashion show, 17 young people filed across the runway…” Or: “Outside of a discotheque are 200 young people…” I’m sure that this shift in perspective would catch the students’ attention and make classes more fun.

However, not to underestimate the magnitude of the subliminal message, there appeared the following: “Of the 20 students in a classroom, 5 are members of the Young Communists League…”

In this same vein, his school is saturated with political murals (standardized murals in which the interests of the students are absent), while the walls are covered with photos of revolutionary heroes, and there’s a hymn that they’re required to repeat daily “with all the enthusiasm it deserves” (as if enthusiasm can be commanded).

Similarly, the nation’s historical figures have to be memorized.

But where is the space for perceiving history for themselves, or their own lives?


Lobby of a school in Roanne.

Do we know how to think?

A friend whose teenage son immigrated to Canada told me that one of the culture shocks he is facing is his “having to think.”

For example, when studying a historical event or figure in school, they aren’t given any prior assessment. He is only asked his opinion, which he described as making him feel as if he were “in the air.”

One detail that caught my attention when I visited several schools in France was not seeing busts of martyrs anywhere, not even outside of schools. Nor were the walls plastered with pictures of national heroes.

The most political statement I saw was in the lobby of one school, it was the inscription “Liberty, Equality, Fraternity.” The murals are made by the students themselves and are around issues of interest to them or ones related directly to their classes.

From the people I met on my book tour, I got the sense that politics in French society is for those who choose to be involved in it. The rest of the population simply leads their own lives, not even the frequent strikes are “nuanced” with ideology.

Mural with images related to my book.

In Cuba, ideology is the first thing that appears in schools, on the job and even in neighborhood groups.


The dull meetings of local Committees for the Defense of the Revolution are essentially political (though carefully timed so as not to conflict with the evening soap opera, because then they’d be that much more depressing).

“Volunteer” work, which is tacitly imposed, is carried out with complete apathy and done only to avoid being branded negatively (in a political sense).

In the neighborhood Report-back Assemblies with our elected delegates, it’s common for a complaint or an expression of dissatisfaction to be prefaced with a proclamation of political loyalty, as if only such people have the right to speak.

It’s as if politics were a safe-conduct pass when actually it’s the obstacle, one that stupefies and separates us.

Mural at a school in Roanne.

No country is constructed with ideologies or wars. Ideologies are (at best) expressions of the inevitable changes in the evolution of collective consciousness.

Wars are the expression of conflict, purging and destruction, where the ultimate aim is to build civility, without silhouettes of guns and rifles in our children’s books or in their games or dreams, like sinister ghosts.

The aim of civility must be pursued without the eternal invocation of an enemy that — in our case — has only served as a goal and refuge for a shameful and endless exodus.

We require civility with schools and children who think of life and not death, of peace, not war. Words have weight, a psychological and even a biological impact, already demonstrated in experiments like in Water Secrets and in the evidence of parapsychology.

Gandhi said: “There is no way to peace. Peace is the way.” I’m sure that peace makes it possible to build a just civility, which is the desire of a good part of humanity – including Cubans.

One thought on “Civility Threatened in Cuba

  • Excellent article Amrit!
    Education is often described as one of the two greatest success stories of the revolution because it eradicated illiteracy from an already high literacy level compared to other countries in Latin America.
    Never mind the shortage of 20,000 teachers, the reality of the Cuban school system is one of education to total obedience and submission, the total opposite of being a true revolutionary!
    The results will be fatal for the next generation.

Comments are closed.